

Law (or Karma) and Grace
Two amazing pieces, both saying essentially the same thing, from two different angles - one contemplative, introspective, and theologically oriented, and one outspoken, public, and secularly oriented. Both powerful and clear: Spirit rules over all, even law! And loving from Spirit is the most important law there is, as is described further in James 2:16-26 at the end of this message, and the implications and ramifications of this are mind-bending, but you must have the courage, first to look, and then to spiral deep within yourself to that soul-stirring place of Truth.
"Growing up in the church, it just made sense to me to be religious. It made sense to be an external Christian, trying to keep an external set of rules. After all, that's what I had always done as a child. I couldn't do and didn't know anything else, because I had always been an external person. So were you, I'm pretty sure, because we all grew up as external people, for the most part, defining ourselves in relation to other persons, things, and events that told us who we were and what was accepted and allowed. That's why new Christians (and new students of anything) are always so prone to asking the relentless external question: 'OK (now that I get that there's something worth getting here), what should I do now?'
But there's no life in the law and trying to 'do' it. The only thing the law tells you is what you ought to do, but can't do, and what you ought not to do, but can't stop doing. It will never relinquish its demand that you ought to do it or ought not to do it, because it's a divine 'ought-to;' God gave it to Moses, after all. We'll keep ourselves under that divine ought-to, and the 'condemnation and death' ministers (2 Corinthians 3), until we learn to live from the 'Person who dwells within us.' Because there's nothing in our flesh and mind that wants to say, 'I can't do it. I can't keep the law through my own effort.' Everything in our flesh and mind says, 'I want to try to do it, and with God's help maybe I can do it.'
Like my friend Burt Rosenburg says, everything in that kind of program is designed for futility, frustration, and failure. But they don't tell you that up front, do they? When you sign up as a new Christian, no one makes this announcement:
WE'VE GOT A WONDERFUL PROGRAM HERE, THE END RESULT OF WHICH WILL BE FUTILITY, FRUSTRATION, AND FAILURE! WHEN YOU HAVE COMPLETED THE COURSE, WE WILL GIVE YOU A DIPLOMA, SAYING:
'CONGRATULATIONS, YOU HAVE FAILED!'
I remember talking to a group and proclaiming, 'We have succeeded! In what? In failing!' And everyone smiled. For we finally recognized that we had succeeded in what we were supposed to do, which was to fail. 'Everyone is telling us that we failed in what we were supposed to succeed in. But the truth is we have succeeded in what we were supposed to fail in. Now we can get on with it. Now we can get on with true life.'
We usually quote Galatians 2:20 apart from its context. It immediately follows Paul's admonition to Peter concerning the law. When Paul said, 'I have been crucified with Christ,' he was referring to his death to the law. Paul was saying, 'The old me died on the cross with Christ, and when I died, I died to trying to keep the law on my own. Trying to keep the law is living according to the flesh, with me and my efforts as my central point of reference. I died to myself as my central point of reference. Now, Christ in me is my central point of reference. He is living His life through me, upon my request.'
As true believers and followers, we no longer live under the law, looking to it to tell us what to do and what not do, then trying our best to do or to not do it. Instead, we live on the faith principle, the inner life principle, of who really is our life - Christ. We trust that He directs us, opens or closes doors for us, and speaks directly to us, giving us a message or whatever is needed for the occasion. We trust that He is living through us. We may not feel it at any given moment, but we live by faith that He is our essential life."
-- Dan Stone, in The Rest of the Gospel: When the partial Gospel has worn you out
"A friend recently sent me a link to an article about U2's Bono (
http://www.christianitytoday.com/music/interviews/2005/bono-0805.html). The article is an excerpt from a book containing Bono's exchange with a French music journalist and friend of the band. Bono's Christian faith has been widely discussed, and in the excerpt he explains his view of Christ. The result is a thoughful and articulate, and sometimes a little confusing, presentation of the Gospel.
Says Bono: 'There's nothing hippie about my picture of Christ. The Gospels paint a picture of a very demanding, sometimes divisive love, but love it is. … The way we would see it, those of us who are trying to figure out our great Christian conundrum, is that the God of the Old Testament is like the journey from stern father to friend. When you're a child, you need clear directions and some strict rules. But with Christ, we have access in a one-to-one relationship, for, as in the Old Testament, it was more one of worship and awe, a vertical relationship. The New Testament, on the other hand, we look across the table at a Jesus who looks familiar, horizontal. The combination is what makes the Cross so compelling.'
Bono's summary seems consistent with a Reformed view of the Testaments, though the language gets a little fuzzy. Another intriguing but puzzling discussion involves the idea of Karma vs. Grace. Bono believes we've moved out of the realm of Karma into one of Grace:
'You see, at the center of all religions is the idea of Karma. You know, what you put out comes back to you: an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, or in physics –in physical laws – every action is met by an equal or opposite reaction. It's intellectually clear to me that Karma is at the very heart of the universe. I'm absolutely sure of it. And yet, along comes this idea (and some occasional experiences) called Grace to upend all that 'as you reap, so you will sow' stuff. Grace seems to defy reason and logic, claiming that love can interrupt, if you like, the consequences of your actions….'
Bono's absolutely right to say that, in grace, God gives us what we don't deserve. But it's not true that the consequences of sin have simply been passed over, a la the dispensationalist view of a 'new law.' The biblical answer is that Christ has actually 'borne' our consequences – our Karma, if you will – in our place.
He seems to then agree with this a little later: 'I'd be in big trouble if Karma was going to finally be my judge…. I'm holding out for Grace. I'm holding out that Jesus took my sins onto the Cross, because I know who I am (in my flesh, at least), and I hope I don't have to depend on my own religiosity.'
Bono's comment about how 'grace seems to defy reason and logic' is a little problematic, but easily rectified by viewing it through a different lens. Paul declared that the whole idea of the cross is 'foolishness' to those who believed in their own perishing. To the Jews it was scandalous, and to the Greeks it just made no sense at all. But what makes it foolish to these folks is that it cuts diametrically against an existing way of thinking, and that's all. It challenges whole systems of thought and worldviews.
The idea is not that grace defies the rules of logic, as if logic belonged to only those who believe a certain way, while we're just hanging on to 'faith.' The issue, instead, is over the proper use of the term, 'logic.' From what message and paradigm are we going to logically reason? From the message of the cross, or from worldly wisdom? Your starting point determines where you end up, and what's logical truly depends on your perspective, and with the cross as the central point of reference, 'grace' is the most 'logical' divine response to our human challenges and griefs that there could be."
-- Chris Alexion
Logical as this response from God may be under the new paradigm of the cross, it still remains the most elusive and hardest to fully receive response, due primarily to our intellectual, "karmic" conditioning, which life then becomes totally about "unlearning."
"Questioning ourselves is of great use in every part of the holy life. Let us be more frequent in this, and in every thing take occasion to discourse with our souls. As places of worship cannot be built or maintained without expense, it may be proper that those who contribute thereto should be accommodated accordingly; but were all persons more spiritually-minded, the lowly, poor, and sick would be treated with more loving attention than usually is the case in worshipping congregations. A lowly state is most favourable for inward peace and for growth in holiness. God would give to all believers riches and honours of this world, if these would do them good, seeing that He has chosen them to be rich in faith, and made them heirs of His kingdom, which He promised to bestow on all who love Him. Consider how often riches lead to vice and mischief, and what great reproaches are thrown upon God and religion by men of wealth, power, and worldly greatness; and it will make this sin appear very sinful and foolish. The Scripture gives as a law, to love our neighbour as ourselves. This law is a Royal law, it comes from the King of kings; and if Christians act unjustly, they are convicted by the law as transgressors. To think that our good deeds will atone for our bad attitude, plainly puts us upon looking for another atonement. According to the covenant of works, one breach of any command brings a man under condemnation for violation of all of them, from which no obedience, past, present, or future, can deliver him. This shows us the happiness of those who are living in Christ, or, more accurately, who have allowed Christ to live through them. We may serve him calmly without slavish fear. God's restraints are not meant as a bondage, but our own corruptions are so. The doom passed upon impenitent sinners, at last, will be judgment without mercy (our karmic reality). But God deems it His glory and joy to pardon, bless, and bestow grace upon those who might justly be condemned at His tribunal; and His grace teaches those who humbly partake of His mercy to copy it into their conduct as a way of being."
-- from Bible Gateway's commentary on James 2
Labels: grace